When I think critically about data and specific visualizations designed to persuade Individuals, I am immediately drawn to the audience and the argument on data and data visualizations. What is it that visualizations are trying to convey? For instance, I chose a visualization from Wendy Sawyer’s work published on July 27, 2020, as part of the Prison Policy Initiative. As my example. This visualization is referencing to Visualizing the racial disparities in mass incarceration. Explicitly addressing the racial disparities in the arrest and confinement of youth:

The visualization conveys that when thinking critically about data and specific visualizations designed to inform and persuade individuals, it is vital to see the argument’s compelling. Children being incarcerated is immediately an eye grabber, yet when you look into the data, you see that these numbers are more than just charts; each data point is a person’s life. This visualization shows the disproportionate rates that youth, particularly those of marginalized communities, are victims of a broken system. The visualization is successful; it is clear that the majority of youth incarcerated are Black while stressing how drastic the difference is and the need to dive into this topic further, asking the question of why. This visualization seeks to highlight the disproportionate rates at which youth of color, mainly Black and Hispanic youth, are arrested and incarcerated compared to their white peers. Illustrating the visualization underscores the need for reform within the criminal justice system. The effectiveness of the visualization is booming, conveying its message using transparent, contrasting colors and comparative bar charts that immediately reveal the disparities. The stark visual comparisons make the argument more persuasive than raw statistics alone. Without the visualization, the content might still be informative but less impactful in showing the scale of inequality. The design suits the data with side-by-side comparisons for different racial groups. This layout lets the viewer quickly identify the racial gaps in incarceration rates. For instance, using a scatter plot may distract viewers and not allow them to have the same level of clarity.
Wendy Sawyer is a researcher at the Prison Policy Initiative, an organization that does substantial work for prison reform and to assist criminal justice. Their background in highlighting disparities and social injustices makes me believe their data visualization was purposeful, as they know the most effective way to let it resonate with their audience. Their audience consists of individuals passionate about prison and criminal justice reform who want to better educate themselves on this matter. It also appears in a research-focused context geared toward policymakers, activists, and academics. Its publication on a platform such as JSTOR indicates a scholarly and policy-oriented audience searching for visualizations to meet their research needs. The data in the visualization comes from government arrest and incarceration records and independent research by the Prison Policy Initiative. I reviewed the accompanying article and dataset on JSTOR, which provides detailed methodology and data citations. The dataset is available in PDF format, although a more accessible spreadsheet version would be helpful for deeper analysis. The creators’ focus on criminal justice reform may introduce a framing bias. While the data is likely accurate, there may be an emphasis on racial disparities without equally highlighting other aspects of the issue, such as socioeconomic factors. When addressing future possibilities, different research questions such as: How have incarceration rates for youth changed over time across various racial groups? What is the role of socioeconomic factors in youth incarceration? It could be beneficial to demonstrate a timeline chart with this. This will display incarceration trends over the years. Another idea is to have an interactive visualization, allowing users to filter by state or demographic, providing a more dynamic data exploration.
References
JSTOR. (n.d.). https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/resrep14449.7.pdf?acceptTC=true&coverpage=false&addFooter=false
Leave a Reply